Why were Chinese city walls often built much thicker than European medieval walls?
Show answer & explanation
Answer: Their rammed-earth cores needed a broad base to stand, so the walls were built as thick banks
Chinese builders lacked the know-how to build thinner walls — Chinese builders put up thin brick walls, tall pagodas and long timber-frame halls whenever those were wanted, so skill was not the limit. A rammed-earth rampart is thick because that is how earth stands and because a wide top was useful, not because anyone was unable to work out a thinner wall.
Chinese cities had far bigger populations to shelter inside — City size is not what sets wall thickness. Some medieval European cities were large too, and a bigger population calls for a longer wall around more ground, not a thicker one. Thickness follows from what the wall is made of and what has to move along its top.
Their rammed-earth cores needed a broad base to stand, so the walls were built as thick banks ✓ — Most Chinese city walls were built as a core of rammed earth, often faced with brick, and earth cannot stand as a thin free-standing wall: it holds its shape only as a broad bank with a wide base, so bases of 10 to 20 metres were normal. The top of such a bank also doubled as a roadway for troops and, later, cannon. Medieval European walls were typically stone or stone-and-mortar, which can hold a steep face only a few metres thick. Same purpose, different material, different shape.
More History & Culture questions
- Why do 12 a.m. and 12 p.m. still feel confusing in a system that otherwise seems familiar?
- What does the French Revolution’s decimal time experiment reveal about changing time systems?
- What made equal-length hours move from specialist astronomy into ordinary daily life?
- Why could an early Egyptian daylight hour be longer in summer than in winter?
- If sunlight could be tracked by shadows, how did ancient Egyptian timekeeping make night fit the same 12-part pattern?
- What did ancient Egyptian sundials and shadow clocks do that helps explain the 12-hour clock face?